All restaurants Call to order
Unclaimed listing — prices are hidden. Call the restaurant to order.Is this your restaurant? Claim it →
Just Like Magic Bakery
Bakery

Just Like Magic Bakery

Pickup Dine-In
+1 570-872-0132 727 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, USA

Slices

Cheesecake SliceSlices

Cheesecake Slice

Slice of cheesecake, can also be purchased as a whole.

Call for pricing
Cake SliceSlices

Cake Slice

Slice of cake, can also be purchased as a whole.

Call for pricing
Pie SliceSlices

Pie Slice

Slice of pie, can also be purchased as a whole.

Call for pricing
Cake Roll SliceSlices

Cake Roll Slice

Slice of cake roll, can also be purchased as a whole.

Call for pricing

Cinnamon Rolls & Pecan Rolls & Bread

Cinnamon RollCinnamon Rolls & Pecan Rolls & Bread

Cinnamon Roll

Fresh cinnamon roll.

Call for pricing
Pecan RollCinnamon Rolls & Pecan Rolls & Bread

Pecan Roll

Fresh pecan roll.

Call for pricing
Specialty RollCinnamon Rolls & Pecan Rolls & Bread

Specialty Roll

Specialty roll.

Call for pricing
Italian BreadCinnamon Rolls & Pecan Rolls & Bread

Italian Bread

Italian bread, call to order.

Call for pricing

Cookies & Macarons

Macaron IndividualCookies & Macarons

Macaron Individual

Individual macaron.

Call for pricing
Cookie Individual (4 oz.)Cookies & Macarons

Cookie Individual (4 oz.)

Individual cookie, 4 oz.

Call for pricing
Cookie Individual (2 oz.)Cookies & Macarons

Cookie Individual (2 oz.)

Individual cookie, 2 oz.

Call for pricing

Brownies

Plain BrownieBrownies

Plain Brownie

Classic plain brownie.

Call for pricing
Cookie BrownieBrownies

Cookie Brownie

Brownie with cookie.

Call for pricing
Mini-BrownieBrownies

Mini-Brownie

Mini brownie.

Call for pricing

Cupcakes & Muffins

Cupcake IndividualCupcakes & Muffins

Cupcake Individual

Individual cupcake. Buy 11 get 1 free.

Call for pricing
Cupcakes Buy 11 Get 1 FreeCupcakes & Muffins

Cupcakes Buy 11 Get 1 Free

Buy 11 cupcakes get 1 free.

Call for pricing
Jumbo CupcakeCupcakes & Muffins

Jumbo Cupcake

Jumbo-sized cupcake.

Call for pricing
Vegan Cupcake IndividualCupcakes & Muffins

Vegan Cupcake Individual

Individual vegan cupcake.

Call for pricing
Gluten Free Cupcake IndividualCupcakes & Muffins

Gluten Free Cupcake Individual

Individual gluten free cupcake.

Call for pricing
Gluten Free Mini Banana BreadCupcakes & Muffins

Gluten Free Mini Banana Bread

Gluten free mini banana bread.

Call for pricing
Muffin IndividualCupcakes & Muffins

Muffin Individual

Individual muffin.

Call for pricing

Additional Desserts

Parfait LargeAdditional Desserts

Parfait Large

Large parfait.

Call for pricing
Parfait SmallAdditional Desserts

Parfait Small

Small parfait.

Call for pricing
Edible Cookie DoughAdditional Desserts

Edible Cookie Dough

A scoop of edible cookie dough with a free topping.

Call for pricing
Cake PucksAdditional Desserts

Cake Pucks

Cake pucks.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Covered PretzelsAdditional Desserts

Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Chocolate covered pretzels.

Call for pricing
Mini Chocolate Chip Banana BreadAdditional Desserts

Mini Chocolate Chip Banana Bread

Mini chocolate chip banana bread.

Call for pricing
MousseAdditional Desserts

Mousse

Mousse dessert.

Call for pricing
Cannoli SmallAdditional Desserts

Cannoli Small

Small cannoli.

Call for pricing
Cannoli LargeAdditional Desserts

Cannoli Large

Large cannoli.

Call for pricing

Beverages

Coffee/Tea/Hot Chocolate SmallBeverages

Coffee/Tea/Hot Chocolate Small

Small hot beverage: coffee, tea, or hot chocolate.

Call for pricing
Coffee/Tea/Hot Chocolate LargeBeverages

Coffee/Tea/Hot Chocolate Large

Large hot beverage: coffee, tea, or hot chocolate.

Call for pricing
Bottled WaterBeverages

Bottled Water

Bottled water.

Call for pricing
Can of SodaBeverages

Can of Soda

Can of soda.

Call for pricing

House Cupcake Flavors

Caramel Pretzel CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Caramel Pretzel Cupcake

Ultimate chocolate cake with rich chocolate buttercream, topped with crushed pretzel and a caramel drizzle.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Lovers CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Lovers Cupcake

Ultimate chocolate cake filled with chocolate sauce and topped with silky chocolate buttercream, chocolate drizzle, chocolate chips, and a chocolate kiss.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Peanut Butter CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake

Chocolate cake topped with peanut butter buttercream, a chocolate drizzle, and chocolate chips.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Raspberry CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Raspberry Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled with raspberry and topped with chocolate buttercream, raspberry drizzle, and chocolate chips.

Call for pricing
Funfetti CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Funfetti Cupcake

Vanilla cake baked with rainbow sprinkles inside, topped with vanilla buttercream and covered in sprinkles.

Call for pricing
Oreo CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Oreo Cupcake

Chocolate cake topped with oreo buttercream, chocolate drizzle, and an oreo cookie on top.

Call for pricing
Peanut Butter Lovers CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Peanut Butter Lovers Cupcake

Peanut butter cake filled with peanut butter sauce, topped with peanut butter buttercream, drizzle, and chunks of Reese's peanut butter cups.

Call for pricing
Red Velvet CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Red Velvet Cupcake

Red velvet cake topped with cream cheese buttercream and red sprinkles.

Call for pricing
S'mores CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

S'mores Cupcake

Ultimate chocolate cake with gooey marshmallow filling, topped with chocolate buttercream, graham cracker crumbs, freeze-dried marshmallows, and a chocolate drizzle.

Call for pricing
Salted Caramel CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Salted Caramel Cupcake

Vanilla cake filled with caramel sauce, topped with caramel buttercream, a sprinkle of salt, caramel drizzle and a caramel candy.

Call for pricing
Samoa CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Samoa Cupcake

Vanilla cake filled with caramel and chocolate sauce, topped with vanilla buttercream, coated in coconut flakes, drizzled with caramel and chocolate, and finished with a samoa cookie.

Call for pricing
Vanilla Oreo CupcakeHouse Cupcake Flavors

Vanilla Oreo Cupcake

Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream, golden oreo crumbs and a golden oreo cookie on top.

Call for pricing

Rotating Cupcake Flavors

Almond Joy CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Almond Joy Cupcake

Ultimate chocolate cake with silky chocolate buttercream, adorned with coconut, caramel, and chocolate drizzles, and finished with a chocolate-covered almond.

Call for pricing
Banana Split CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Banana Split Cupcake

Vanilla cake filled with banana pudding, banana buttercream, topped with nuts, chocolate syrup, and a cherry.

Call for pricing
Blissfuls CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Blissfuls Cupcake

Soft vanilla cake topped with creamy cookie butter buttercream.

Call for pricing
Brown Sugar Butterscotch CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Brown Sugar Butterscotch Cupcake

Butterscotch cake topped with creamy vanilla buttercream.

Call for pricing
Brownie Explosion CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Brownie Explosion Cupcake

Ultimate chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream and generous chunks of brownie, drizzled with chocolate.

Call for pricing
Butterfinger CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Butterfinger Cupcake

Vanilla cake with Butterfinger pieces in the batter, crowned with vanilla buttercream and more Butterfinger crumbles.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cupcake

Vanilla cake with a heart of edible cookie dough, topped with vanilla icing and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Mint CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Mint Cupcake

Decadent chocolate cake crowned with a cool chocolate-mint buttercream.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Salted Caramel CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Salted Caramel Cupcake

Rich chocolate cake beneath caramel buttercream, accented with sea salt and a caramel drizzle.

Call for pricing
Chocolate Strawberry CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Chocolate Strawberry Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled with strawberry filling and topped with chocolate buttercream mixed with freeze-dried strawberries.

Call for pricing
Fluffer Nutter CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Fluffer Nutter Cupcake

Light vanilla cake paired with smooth peanut butter buttercream.

Call for pricing
Galaxy CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Galaxy Cupcake

Rich ultimate chocolate cake paired with silky vanilla buttercream.

Call for pricing
Heath CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Heath Cupcake

Rich chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream and crushed Heath bar.

Call for pricing
Hint O Mint CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Hint O Mint Cupcake

Tender vanilla cake topped with mint-infused vanilla buttercream and crowned with Andes Candies.

Call for pricing
Lemon Coconut CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Lemon Coconut Cupcake

Zesty lemon cake with coconut buttercream, dipped in shredded coconut.

Call for pricing
Lemon Raspberry CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Lemon Raspberry Cupcake

Zesty lemon cake with raspberry filling, vanilla buttercream, and a raspberry drizzle.

Call for pricing
Love that Nila CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Love that Nila Cupcake

Creamy vanilla cake with smooth vanilla buttercream, drizzled with vanilla, sprinkled with festive sprinkles, and topped with a Nilla wafer.

Call for pricing
M&M CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

M&M Cupcake

Vanilla cake bursting with mini M&Ms, topped with vibrant vanilla buttercream and more mini M&Ms.

Call for pricing
Malt Shoppe CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Malt Shoppe Cupcake

Nostalgic chocolate cake with a creamy chocolate-Ovaltine buttercream.

Call for pricing
Nutter Butter CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Nutter Butter Cupcake

Light vanilla cake paired with smooth peanut butter buttercream.

Call for pricing
Reese Pieces CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Reese Pieces Cupcake

Vanilla cake with Reese's in the batter, crowned with peanut butter buttercream and sprinkled with Reese's Pieces.

Call for pricing
Ruby Red CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Ruby Red Cupcake

Classic red velvet cake adorned with luscious vanilla buttercream.

Call for pricing
Razzle Dazzle CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Razzle Dazzle Cupcake

Chocolate cake with vibrant raspberry buttercream and a luscious drizzle of raspberry sauce.

Call for pricing
The Stroud CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

The Stroud Cupcake

Classic vanilla cake with fluffy vanilla buttercream and mini chocolate chips scattered throughout.

Call for pricing
The Winterfest CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

The Winterfest Cupcake

Bright lemon cake paired with lemon blackberry buttercream.

Call for pricing
Ultimate Oreo CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Ultimate Oreo Cupcake

Ultimate chocolate cake with cream filling, topped with vanilla buttercream mixed with chunks of Oreo and a chocolate drizzle.

Call for pricing
Vanilla Raspberry CupcakeRotating Cupcake Flavors

Vanilla Raspberry Cupcake

Tender vanilla cake with a sweet raspberry filling.

Call for pricing

Ratings & reviews

Food and service, rated out of 10 by diners.

—
out of 10
0 reviews
Food—/10
Service—/10

No reviews yet — be the first to rate this restaurant!